So, yesterday night I went to Metro TV, a national TV station, to watch a new show called East-West Connection. It was basically a teleconference between a studio audience & panel in Jakarta with a studio audience & panel in the USA.
I was promised the opportunity to ask questions to US audience from across the globe but ended up disappointed as the opportunity to ask questions was only given to the panel (Amien Rais and another gentleman whose name I’ve forgotten) and certain members of the audience who represented groups like the Freedom Institute and other think tanks…
Despite the disappointment that I had to endure, it was quite an interesting discussion about America’s effort in waving the democratic flag around the world amidst its war on terrorism and how Indonesia plays an important role in these efforts (read: a doll needed to portray an image of the so-called Moderate-Muslim Nation within this clash of values).
Excuse my skepticism, but this use of term: Moderate-Muslim Nation, never fails to disgust me… I mean I have nothing against the concept of a moderate Muslim. As a matter of fact I tend to identify myself as one… What I find terribly appalling is that this image is a terrible misrepresentation of Indonesia. The fact is we have five main religions, each parted up into different sects and beliefs making this concept of a ‘Moderate-Muslim majority’ an over-generalization of what Indonesia is. Saying that the 90% of Muslims in Indonesia are generally Moderate-Muslims is quite an overstatement because what does it really mean to be a Moderate-Muslim?
What many people do not know is that every Indonesian MUST choose among the five religions (Islam, Christianity, Catholic, Hinduism, and Buddhism) and this is written on their ID Card. This means, even if you’re an atheist or agnostic you still have to declare one of the religions above…
So again, what does it mean to be a Moderate Muslim? Someone who’s registered as a Muslim but doesn’t practice the religion? Someone who practices Islam in certain parts of his/her life but not in others? Someone who practices Islam but refuses to resort into fundamentalism?
What does this mean? This promotion of Indonesia as a Moderate-Muslim Nation often reeks with politics and the desperate need of aid… And as a result it neglects the multi-religious face that Indonesia really represents. America needs a Moderate-Muslim friend… Indonesia has step up to the occasion… But who is this Indonesia that we’re all talking about? It definitely is not the Indonesia that I know.
Dhika*Shines